Yudhawira Khatulistiwa Ad Banner 150x30

Last Update:
Wed, April 23, 2003 4:01 PM
 

Navigation Arc
Stand-Alone Products
Remote Access Servers
  • Cyclades PR4000
  • Terminal Servers
  • TS1000      
  • TS2000      
  • PR3000/TS
     
  • Routers
  • PR1000
  • PR2000
  • PR3000
     
  •  

    Console Access Servers

    Product Comparison Chart

    Intro | Why...? | Top
     

    This document positions the Cyclades-TS2000 against other Console Port Management products in the market. The TS2000 is unique because it combines features from traditional console management products with the connectivity and security of terminal servers and flexibility of server-based solutions.

    Console Access Servers
     

    Looking at existing products, we can identify three distinct categories:

    Traditional Console Access Servers

    Console Port Management is not a new application. Besides using outdated technology and being expensive, traditional console access products have not been able to follow the changes required by the increase in size of the server farms and the need for Internet connectivity. They focus on hardware rather than software-based scalability and modularity and present poor connectivity and security features.

    The Lightwave ConsoleServer 3200 and Apex Viewpoint are good examples of traditional console access products.

    Generic Terminal Servers

    Terminal Servers were used to connect serial terminals to Unix Systems. Some of those products have incorporated software features to adapt to the Console Access function. They usually come with strong Internet connectivity and security functions, but lack specific console features (convenient cabling, high port density, visual indication of the status of the ports, etc.).

    Examples of good terminal servers that are also used as console access servers are the Computone RAS2000, Lucent Portmaster 2, Lantronix, Xyplex, Cisco 2511, and Cyclades-PR3000.

    PC-based Terminal Servers

    With the availability of PC hardware and open source OSes such as Linux and FreeBSD, building a terminal server by installing a multi-port serial board in a PC becomes a viable proposition for some users. These solutions are weak in port density and integration, but present potential advantages in scalability and flexibility to accommodate specific needs.

    Cyclades offers multi-port serial boards such as the Cyclades-Z, which are frequently used for this purpose.

    Intro | Why...? | Top
     

    Why is the TS2000 the best Console Access solution?

    The TS2000 was specifically designed for Console Access and combines the features from Console Access Servers with the security of Terminal Servers and flexibility of server-based solutions. This is demonstrated in the following comparison chart.

    Products

    Cyclades

    Cyclades-TS2000

    Lightwave

    Console3200
    (Traditional)

    Computone

    RAS2000
    (Generic TS)

    Cyclades

    Cyclades-Z
    (Server Based)

    Physical

    Construction

    Single box
    Single board

    Single box
    Multi board

    Single box
    Multi Board

    Multi Box
    Multi Board

    Hardware

    50MHz PPC
    32MB RAM
    4MB Flash

    Undisclosed

    20MHz MIPS
    4MB RAM
    512kb ROM

    Intel x86
    64MB RAM
    Hard Disk

    Dual Power

    No

    Optional

    No

    Optional

    Spurious Break safe?

    Yes

    Yes

    No

    No

    LED Status

    Yes

    No

    No

    No

    Port Density

    Maximum

    32 / 1U

    10 / 1U

    16 / 1U

    13 /1U

    16 ports
    32 ports
    64 ports

    1U
    1U
    2U

    3U
    3U
    6U

    4U
    4U
    4U

    2U
    3U
    5U

    Scalability

    Per chassis

    32

    32

    64

    256

    Stackable

    Yes

    No

    Yes

    No

    Interfaces

    Ethernet

    10BT, 100BT 10BT only 10BT only 10BT, 100BT

    RS-232

    RJ-45 RJ-45 RJ-45 RJ-45

    Dialup

    External modem Expansion Card External modem External modem

    Security

    RADIUS

    Yes No Yes Yes

    IP Filtering

    Yes No Yes Yes

    SSH

    Yes No Yes Yes

    Features

    Sessions

    Unlimited 17 per chassis Unlimited Unlimited

    Buffering

    Server-based Local, 64KB Server-based Unlimited

    Port Access

    Manual/Menu
    Telnet IP Addr.
    Telnet TCP Port
    TCP socket
    Manual/Menu Manual/Menu
    Telnet IP Addr.
    Telnet TCP Port
    Manual/Menu
    Telnet IP Addr.
    Telnet TCP Port
    TCP Socket

    SW Upgrade

    Yes (Flash) Yes (unknown) No (ROM) Yes (Hard Disk)

    SW Base

    Linux Proprietary Proprietary Linux, FreeBSD

    MSRP Price

    16 ports
    32 ports
    64 ports

    $2161
    $2741
    $5482
    $7960
    $9940
    $19880
    $3995
    $4990
    $6980
    $2450
    $3350
    $4375
    Notes: The chart above is based on information published by the product manufacturers and available on 01/22/01. The information on server-based solutions is highly dependent on user-provided hardware and software. We have not verified that the products offer the functionality claimed in the product literature. Cyclades and Computone prices are from the published MSRP list. Lightwave Communications prices were provided by the vendor as a quotation. Server-based prices are estimated. Cyclades prices are all inclusive. Lighwave prices don’t include some optional hardware items.

    Intro | Why...? | Top | Back to TS Series
     
     
     
    < Home     Profile     Products     Support     Services    Reseller     Our Clients     Contact Us >
    © 2001 YudhaWira Khatulistiwa
    Best viewed with Microsoft Internet Explorer 5.0 or later
    Click to go to service page Click to contact us ( Temporarily please use links below) Click to see Resellers Click to go to product page Homing to mainpage Click to read the Company Profile Click to go to Support page Click to see the clients